Duazary / Vol. 20, No. 4 – 2023 / 242 - 251
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21676/2389783X.5383
Diana Rivera-Rujana1, Luz Tovar-Ruiz2, Diana Muñoz-Rodríguez3, Angie Jácome-Jácome4, Angie Suarez-Guerrero5, Gustavo Cuatin-Morales6
1. Universidad del Cauca. Popayán, Colombia. Correo: dianarivera@unicauca.edu.co - https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5862-8130
2. Universidad del Cauca, Popayán, Colombia. Correo: latovar@unicauca.edu.co - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1912-4893
3. Universidad CES. Medellín, Colombia. Correo: dmunoz@ces.edu.co - https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4255-4813
4. Universidad del Cauca. Ipiales, Colombia. Correo: angieja@unicauca.edu.co - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2773-064X
5. Universidad del Cauca. Bogotá, Colombia. Correo: angiesua@unicauca.edu.co - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1301-9056
6. Universidad del Cauca. Pasto, Colombia. Correo: gustavocuatin@unicauca.edu.co - https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7603-4771
How to cite this article: Rivera-Rujana D, Tovar-Ruiz L, Muñoz-Rodríguez D, Jácome-Jácome A, Suarez-Guerrero A, Cuatin-Morales G Perfil clínico y epidemiológico de la parálisis cerebral infantil en Antioquia, Cauca y Nariño, Colombia. Duazary. 2023;20(4):242-251. https://doi.org/10.21676/2389783X.5383
Received on July 06, 2023
Accepted on December 29, 2023
Posted online December 31, 2023
Introduction: Cerebral palsy (CP) is a group of movement and posture development disorders that limit activity, impact participation, and affect the quality of life of children. It is the most common cause of motor disability and represents a public health issue. Associated risk factors and clinical characteristics remain unknown. Objetive: To determine the clinical and epidemiological profile of CP within the participating population. Method: An observational, descriptive, cross-sectional, and retrospective study of 330 children with CP from three departments in Colombia. Results: Male sex, prenatal infection (12.4%), prolonged labor (24.2%), and neonatal asphyxia (17.3%) were the most frequent associated factors with CP. Children who reached early motor milestones did so thirteen months later compared to typical motor development. Only 15% of the studied children exceeded all dimensions of the Gross motor function measure (GMFM-66), and 14% failed to perform any motor tasks. Conclusions: Term birth with prolonged labor complication was the main associated factor with CP found in this study. Investigating prenatal care and perinatal attention in the country is suggested to prevent this disorder.
Introducción: la parálisis cerebral infantil (PCI) es un grupo de trastornos del desarrollo del movimiento y la postura, limita la actividad, impacta en la participación y afecta la calidad de vida de los niños. Es la causa más común de discapacidad motora y representa un problema de salud pública. Se desconocen los factores de riesgo asociados y las características clínicas. Objetivo: determinar el perfil clínico y epidemiológico de la PCI en la población participante. Método: estudio observacional, descriptivo, transversal con intención analítica y retrospectivo de 330 niños con PCI, de 3 departamentos de Colombia. Resultados: el sexo masculino, infección prenatal (12,4%), parto prolongado (24,2%) y asfixia neonatal (17,3%) fueron los factores asociados más frecuentes con la PCI. Los niños que alcanzaron los hitos motores tempranos, lo hicieron trece meses después respecto al desarrollo motor típico. Solo el 15% de los niños estudiados superaron todas las dimensiones de Gross motor function measure (GMFM-66) y el 14% no logró realizar ninguna tarea motora. Conclusiones: el nacimiento a término con complicación de parto prolongado fue el principal factor asociado con PCI encontrado en este estudio. Se sugiere investigar el control prenatal y atención perinatal en el país con el fin de prevenir este trastorno.
Infantile cerebral palsy (ICP) is a group of disorders of the development of movement and posture, with non-progressive characteristics and secondary to injury to the developing brain1-5, which limit activity and participation, affecting the quality of life of the child population6. ICP generally results from events that occur before, during, or after childbirth and is commonly accompanied by sensory, perceptual, cognitive, communication, and behavioral disorders5. It is classified as spastic, ataxic, dystonic, and mixed forms. It obeys criteria such as the impairment of muscle tone, the characteristics of the movements, and the postural patterns that the child presents5,7. It is also classified according to the topographic distribution into monoparesis/monoplegia, hemiparesis/hemiplegia, diparesis/diplegia, and tetraparesis/tetraplegia, with predominant involvement of a single limb of the body, a hemibody, the lower limbs and all four extremities, respectively5.
The diagnosis of ICP is complex and occurs over the long term, generally at the age of one or two years8. It is performed based on a neurological evaluation, identification of risk factors, and neuroimaging tests. Currently, there is no cure for this condition; management is done with a comprehensive approach seeking the maximum degree of functional independence of the child in its context5,8.
It is estimated that the incidence of ICP in the world is 2.0 to 3.5 cases per 1000 live births7, while other studies have expressed that the prevalence of ICP ranges from 1.5 to 2.5 per 1000 live births1,2,4,8,9. The difference between developed countries and those in conditions of poverty is notable, such as some African countries that report up to ten cases per 1,000 live births; in developing countries such as Peru, up to five cases are observed for every 1000 live births1, while in others such as Australia, Europe, Canada, Sweden, China and Japan, a decrease in prevalence is evident mainly among premature and low birth weight newborns2,3,8,9.
The National Disability Observatory in Colombia reported that for the year 2012, 1.2% of children from 0 to 17 years old had some disability; however, there is no specific information on the prevalence of ICP in the country1.
ICP represents a severe public health problem worldwide since it is the most common cause of motor disability in childhood1-3,6,7,9. It is a common pathology that significantly affects the quality of life of children and their families10. In the United States alone, the costs associated with this disease exceed 11.5 billion dollars annually, making it the second developmental disability with the highest personal and institutional expenditure in that country, which highlights the importance of identifying the associated risk factors as a preventive element2.9.
Colombia does not currently have an epidemiological surveillance program for ICP, so associated risk factors, causes, and consequences are unknown. Additionally, the studies carried out on it are limited2. Identifying the factors that may lead this population group to suffer from this disorder is essential. This information would allow the development of activities to prevent the disease and promote health, which in the long term would reduce the high costs used in its care9.
The objective was to determine the clinical and epidemiological profile of children with ICP from Colombia's Antioquia, Cauca, and Nariño departments.
A descriptive study was conducted.
The study population consisted of 330 children diagnosed with ICP who attended outpatient clinics in different institutions. health, foundations, and different programs of the Colombian Institute of Family Welfare in Colombia's Nariño, Cauca, and Antioquia departments.
Those who responded to the open call made through the communication channels of the participating universities during the years 2018 and 2019 with a confirmed medical diagnosis of ICP, were minors, and had informed consent signed by their parents or legal representative were included. Patients were evaluated at the care sites they attended regularly. The evaluations were carried out by physiotherapists trained to complete the instrument.
Clinical data were obtained through the application of an instrument that investigated the following aspects: 1) personal data: sex and age; 2) medical diagnosis: type of ICP; 3) risk factors associated with the development of ICP: weeks of gestation, type of delivery, weight, height and head circumference at birth (head growth percentiles), prenatal, perinatal, postnatal and family history; 4) nutrition; 5) history of motor development achieved and 6) aspects of maternal health: number of pregnancies, number of abortions (induced and spontaneous). These instruments were applied to the minors' parents or caregivers (legal representatives), consulting the child's medical history as a secondary source. In the history component, both prenatal, perinatal, and postnatal were consulted in the clinical history of the minors; due to their diversity, the most frequent ones were presented, and categories called “others” were made to group those with less frequency.
Some of the background information at each stage is listed to generate greater understanding:
Prenatal: Oligohydramnios, general death, non-development of uterine arteries, emotional stress, asthmatic crisis, premature rupture of membranes, appendectomy in gestation, multiple pregnancy, hematoma, agenesis of the corpus callosum, placenta previa, malformation of the umbilical cord, placenta previa, irradiation due to traffic accident, fetal distress, gestational diabetes, preterm birth syndrome, premature birth, Help syndrome, hydrocephalus, substance abuse, depression, pre-infarction loss of amniotic fluid, and schizencephaly.
Perinatal: Hypoxia, cord circularity, low APGAR, placental abruption, prematurity, acute fetal distress, mechanical ventilation, home birth, non-dilation, induced labor, preeclampsia, use of forceps, maternal fever, and encephalopathy.
Postnatal: Meningitis, anemia, encephalopathy, seizure syndrome, neonatal depression, cardiopulmonary arrest, bacterial infection, poisoning, hydrocephalus, pneumonia, Arnold Chiari syndrome, and falls.
The data were analyzed in the SPSS version 22 statistical package. Using univariate techniques, absolute and relative frequencies were estimated for the qualitative variables. In contrast, the normality distribution was tested using the Shapiro-Wilk test for the quantitative variables to explore the possibility of applying methods based on a normal distribution. All quantitative variables had a distribution other than normal, so they were presented through medians with their interquartile ranges (IQR).
Crude prevalence ratios were estimated to identify the strength of association of the independent variables on the type of ICP, and the Kruskal-Wallis test was used to analyze the independent data. Spearman's correlation hypothesis test was used to find correlations.
This study complied with the bioethical principles established in the Declaration of Helsinki, the guidelines of Resolution 8430 of the Ministry of Health for Colombia and the research divisions, and the endorsement of the research ethics committee of the University of Cauca and CES University, all expressed in the informed consent. Each survey administered was given a numerical code to protect the confidentiality of the participants (Statutory Law 1581 of 2012).
This study included 330 participants with ICP, mostly male, represented by 62.1% (n=205), with a median age of 9 years (IQR=6.00-13.0). The most frequent clinical form of ICP was the spastic type, with 60% (n=198). 23.3% of ICPs in this study are not specified. The median birth weight was 2800 grams (IQR=1890-3210), while the median height was 49cm (IQR=45-51). In one out of every three children, the head circumference was below the 50th percentile, and 31% were above it. Only one in every hundred children was born with an expected head circumference (at the percentile) for age. The median weeks of gestation were 38th week (IQR=35-39). The general characteristics of children with ICP are described below—more information in Table 1.
Regarding these variables, the correlation (Spearman) of birth weight and weeks of gestation was direct and substantial with a Rho=0.77 (p=<0.001). Given that the variables weeks of gestation and birth weight did not show a normal distribution, the Kruskal-Wallis test was used, obtaining that in the study population, neither the weeks of gestation (p=0.68) nor the birth weight birth (p=0.19) showed an association with a specific type of ICP.
Among the most common prenatal histories, prenatal infection (12.8%) and preeclampsia (8.8%) were found in perinatal history, prolonged labor (24.2%), and neonatal cyanosis (16.6%). Asphyxia (17.3%) and jaundice (11.5%) were the most common postnatal history. Regarding family history, it was found that 41.8% reported hypertension, diabetes mellitus in 28.2%, cancer in 28.8%, and epilepsy in 10.6%. See Table 2.
Characteristics | Frequency | % |
---|---|---|
Gender Male Female |
ㅤ 205 125 |
ㅤ 62,1 37,9 |
ICP Type Spastic Dyskinetics Hypotonic Mixed Not specified |
ㅤ 198 23 19 13 77 |
ㅤ 60,0 7,0 5,8 3,9 23,3 |
Head circunference At the 50th percentile Below the 50th percentile Above the 50th percentile Unspecified |
ㅤ 90 82 27 63 |
ㅤ 34,4 31,3 10,3 24,0 |
Variable | Range | Median | IQR |
---|---|---|---|
Birth weight (gr) Minimum Maximum |
ㅤ 500 4800 |
ㅤ 2800,0 ㅤ |
ㅤ 1890 - 2310 ㅤ |
Size at birth (cm) Minimum Maximum Gestation (weeks) Minimum Maximum |
ㅤ 13 97 ㅤ 20 43 |
ㅤ ㅤ 49,0 ㅤ ㅤ 38,0 ㅤ |
ㅤ ㅤ 45,0 - 51,0 ㅤ ㅤ 35,0 - 39,0 ㅤ |
IQR: Interquartile range. Gr: grams. Cm: centimeters.
In the exploration of possible associations of history on the types of ICP, it was found that compared with spastic type ICP, having prenatal infection can increase the risk of hypotonic ICP by 30% and of mixed ICP by 45%. Within the perinatal history, prolonged labor increases the risk of having hypotonic ICP by 2.49 times and the risk of having dyskinetic type ICP by 39%. Neonatal asphyxia, as the most prevalent factor in postnatal history, was not associated with any of the forms of ICP. Table 3 shows the estimates of prevalence ratios for the most prevalent antecedents in each stage of the child: prenatal, perinatal, and postnatal.
Prenatal | Frequency | % |
---|---|---|
Others prenatal infection Preeclampsia Medication consumption Hemorrhage Trauma Hyperemesis Poisoning |
77 41 29 18 17 17 14 4 |
22,3 12,4 8,8 5,5 5,2 5,2 4,2 1,2 |
Perinatal prolonged labor Others Neonatal cyanosis Cardiorespiratory arrest Neonatal depression Meconium aspiration Breech presentation Eclampsia |
ㅤ 80 79 53 28 20 19 11 9 |
ㅤ 24,2 23,9 16,1 8,5 6,1 5,8 3,3 2,0 |
Postnatal Others Neonatal asphyxia Jaundice Postnatal infection Bronchoaspiration Apnea congenital defect Hypoglycemia |
ㅤ 132 57 38 22 19 17 17 9 |
ㅤ 40,0 17,3 11,5 6,7 5,8 5,2 5,2 2,7 |
The clinical profile of children with ICP allows us to recognize risk factors, identify the characteristics of this condition, and provide critical information for early diagnosis. Case identification ensures timely intervention and avoids further impact on the child's quality of life.
The clinical profile of children with ICP allows us to recognize risk factors, identify the characteristics of this condition, and provide critical information for early diagnosis. Case identification ensures timely intervention and avoids further impact on the child's quality of life.
The clinical profile of children with ICP allows us to recognize risk factors, identify the characteristics of this condition, and provide critical information for early diagnosis. Case identification ensures timely intervention and avoids further impact on the child's quality of life.
Male sex is related to the prevalence of ICP in this study, a relationship that is confirmed in similar studies carried out worldwide11. Population samples from Latin American studies in Mexico4, Ecuador12, Argentina13, and Peru14 corroborate the prevalence of ICP in males, reporting a higher percentage. Although Colombia does not present specific data on ICP, it reports that motor disability in children is predominant in the male gender15; an isolated national study carried out in Cali in a pediatric population with a diagnosis of ICP showed predominance in the same gender1.
Background | ICP Type | ㅤ | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Hypotonic | Dyskinetic | Mixed | Spastic | |
PR (p-value) | PR (p-value) | PR (p-value) | ㅤ | |
Prenatal: Infection Perinatal: prolonged labor Postnatal: asphyxiation |
1,3 (0,7) 2,4 (0,03)* 0,3 (0,3) |
0,6 (0,6) 1,3 (0,02)* 1,02 (0,9) |
1,4 (0,04)* 1,9 (0,09) 0,9 (0,9) |
1,0 1,0 1,0 |
*Statistically significant.
The most common clinical type of ICP was spastic, a finding similar to those reported by other national and global studies7,11,12,14. Wimalasundera et al8 reported that this type occurs more frequently when the damage is associated with prematurity, a cause with low frequency in the participating population. On the other hand, in Uganda, a low-income country, dyskinetic ICP is the most common in children aged between 2 and 7 years16.
Head circumference is an essential measure in the evaluation of the child because it assesses brain growth17,18. However, it is crucial to consider that more than a third of the population participating in this study had head circumferences in the appropriate percentile, a fact similar to a study of nutritional status in children with ICP, where only 8.5% of the participants had alterations in the head circumference, which may indicate that the appropriate percentile does not rule out brain damage19.
Currently, in Colombia, the strategy used to evaluate the risk of morbidity and mortality during pregnancy, childbirth, and the postpartum period for the mother-child binomial, to intervene in risk factors early, is prenatal control, the start of these after the first trimester or having less than four are described as predictive of maternal and infant morbidity and mortality. Despite having insurance coverage of more than 87%, maternal morbidity and mortality continue to have a high incidence. Insurance, cost, educational level, socioeconomic stratum, geographic access, and social and family support have been recorded as barriers to access to prenatal control20,21.
On the other hand, prenatal infection, a predominant finding in this study, is defined as one of the main risk factors associated with ICP2,3. Riquelme-Heras et al4 found that urinary infection with 43% was the most frequent risk factor in a study of 230 people with ICP. Michael-Asalu et al3 stated that fever and maternal infection are associated with a significant risk of ICP since it causes damage to the white matter, and Korzeniewski et al9 stated that maternal infections could induce ICP by transmitting pathogens to the fetus and causing persistent systemic inflammation.
Premature birth is one of the most critical risk factors for ICP2-4,16,23, mainly for those newborns with less than 28 weeks of gestation3. In developed countries, technological advances and the implementation of prevention strategies in perinatal care services have led to the more remarkable survival of newborns, especially very premature children with low birth weight, who are at greater risk of deficiencies and disability23; however, gestational age predominated in the study population. The most common perinatal history was prolonged labor, which has direct repercussions on the health of the newborn2,23. In Colombia, it was reported that 3.1% of total disabilities originated from complications during childbirth15, and studies conducted in Peru, India, and Pakistan found an association between prolonged labor and perinatal asphyxia23. This situation represents a health problem with high rates of maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality in low-income countries24,25.
In the US, 98% of women plan an institutionalized birth, given that they consider the hospital a safe and comfortable place to give birth26. This information contrasts with the preference of some women to have a birth at home, in their autonomy and comfort, as well as according to their social representations and geographical contexts27. In Latin American countries like Peru, home births mainly occur in poor rural areas, where there is difficult geographic access and late care for pregnant women28. In Colombia, some ethnic minorities prefer home birth, such as the Nasa and Misak women of Cauca and Wayúu women, due to the absence of health services that correspond with their traditional practices and their identity values, as well as the difficult access to a hospital medical care promptly, excessive medicalization, and loss of humanized care during childbirth29,30.
Regarding postnatal risk factors, it was found that neonatal asphyxia prevailed in the present study, unlike what was reported in other studies worldwide, where convulsive syndrome, jaundice, and craniocerebral trauma were the risk factors. In the postnatal period, it was found more frequently3,4.
Regarding family history, chronic non-communicable diseases, including hypertension, were the most frequently found family history31. It can be stated that there is a relationship between the chronic illnesses of parents and risk factors associated with ICP, as stated by Buck et al. 32; they found that where the chronic illness of parents with the highest prevalence in the group of men was hypertension while in the group of women, it was mood and anxiety, in both cases the chronic disease was negatively associated with gestation and birth weight.
On the other hand, it is essential to remember that optimal intrauterine balance is vital for the development of the fetus and that this environment is highly vulnerable to pregnancy disorders, including pregnancy-induced hypertension and preeclampsia2,33. Blair et al34 found that the presence of these entities statistically significantly increased the frequency of ICP in term births and decreased it in preterm births in a statistically non-significant manner in an Australian population. Likewise, a direct relationship can be established between the presence of preeclampsia and the decrease in birth weight, and in turn, the decrease in birth weight as an established risk for the development of cardiovascular diseases in the child33. In another study on children with ICP carried out in Japan, it was stated that pregnant mothers who presented preeclampsia during pregnancy had more minor children in weight and gestational age31.
Related to socioeconomic level, a Korean study shows that the incidence of ICP was significantly lower among high social strata than low social strata, even more noticeable in the group of medical assistance beneficiaries35. A similar situation occurred in an isolated study in Mexico, where 89% of the participants belonged to the low and lower-middle socioeconomic levels. In Colombia, it could be compared with the lower socioeconomic income and the beneficiaries of the System for the Identification of Potential Beneficiaries of Social Programs (SISBEN). According to the Ministry of Health statistics, 83% of people registered in the Registry of Location and Characterization of People with Disabilities belong to low socioeconomic income. However, no distinction was made by age group.
Most of the literature found that prematurity is a factor highly related to the development of ICP. However, the results obtained in this research indicate that most births were full-term. The most significant factor associated with ICP was prolonged labor. Further research is required to identify the main factors associated with prenatal, perinatal, and postnatal care to implement intervention measures that promote prevention, adequate care, and safe delivery.
More research is required on the clinical profile of children with ICP in Colombia and Latin American countries, identifying and associating sociodemographic factors that directly or indirectly influence this, allowing analysis and surveillance of health care models for children, pregnant mothers, and newborn children.
The epidemiological record of children with ICP, as well as its adequate follow-up, is necessary to understand better this population's status and the risk factors that influence their condition. This knowledge can then generate public policies, improvements, or modifications in the health system that reduce the incidence of ICP and, consequently, the prevalence of childhood disability in the country.
We thank the children and their families for their invaluable contribution to the development of this research and the funding universities, the University of Cauca as an internal development project VRI ID4688, and the minimum call for applications from the University CES, Medellín, Colombia (Imputación INV.022019.014).
The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest in this research.
The first author participated in project coordination, data collection management, methodological design approach, administrative management before the University of Cauca, analysis of results, supervision, review, and editing. The second author conducted the data analysis, wrote the draft, reviewed it, and edited it. The third author designed and constructed the methodology, administrative management before the CES University, data processing, statistical analysis, review, and editing. The fourth author participated in data collection, results analysis, and draft writing. The fifth author conducted the data collection, results analysis, and draft writing. The sixth author participated in data collection, results analysis, and draft writing.